From: Sink mobility aware energy-efficient network integrated super heterogeneous protocol for WSNs
Protocol | Achievement | Reference | Price to pay | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|
iMBEENISH | More alive nodes | Fig. 7 | Rate of CH selection | |
 | Packets sent to BS | Fig. 8 | Distance computation between CH and BS | Fig. 4 |
 | Packets received at BS | Fig. 9 | Sink movement to the CHs | Fig. 6 |
 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 | Energy consumption |  |
MBEENISH | More alive nodes | Fig. 7 | Sharp energy depletion | Â |
 | Packets sent to BS | Fig. 8 | Distance computation between CH and BS | Fig. 4 |
 | Packets received at BS | Fig. 9 | Sink movement to the CHs | Fig. 3 |
 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 | Lower stability period | Fig. 1 |
iBEENISH | More alive nodes | Fig. 7 | Sharp energy depletion | Â |
 | Packets sent to BS | Fig. 8 | Changes CH selection probability dynamically | Fig. 10 |
 | Packets received at BS | Fig. 9 | CH selection of high-energy nodes | Fig. 10 |
 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 | Redundant transmission |  |
BEENISH | More alive nodes | Fig. 7 | Sharp energy depletion due to four types of nodes | Fig. 1 |
 | Packets sent to BS | Fig. 8 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 |
 | Packets received at BS | Fig. 9 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 |
 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 | Sudden energy depletion |  |
EDEEC | More alive nodes | Fig. 7 | Energy consumption due to three nodes forwarding | Â |
 | Packets sent to BS | Fig. 8 | Throughput decreases due to packets loss in the midway | Fig. 9 |
 | Packets received at BS | Fig. 9 | Distant propagations | Fig. 5 |
 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 | More complexity involved |  |
DDEEC | More alive nodes | Fig. 7 | Energy consumption due to two nodes forwarding | Â |
 | Packets sent to BS | Fig. 8 | As rounds pass, advanced nodes will have the same CH selection probability like that of the normal ones | Fig. 10 |
 | Packets received at BS | Fig. 9 | CH selection | Fig. 10 |
 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 | Redundant transmission and lower stability period | Fig. 7 |
DEEC | More alive nodes | Fig. 7 | Overhead and complexity of forming clusters | Fig. 10 |
 | Packets sent to BS | Fig. 8 | Less alive nodes | Fig. 7 |
 | Packets received at BS | Fig. 9 | Less alive nodes | Fig. 7 |
 | Rate of CH selection | Fig. 10 | Packets sent and received at BS |