Skip to main content

Table 1 Result comparison of the CAPSO method versus standard PSO, IPSO, and APSO methods

From: Antenna array design by a contraction adaptive particle swarm optimization algorithm

Method

f(·)

Mean

std

p

PSO

f 1

1099.20

434.68

2.16E −7

 

f 2

4033.60

32.00

7.31E −6

IPSO

f 1

908.80

222.27

2.37E −7

 

f 2

3072.00

448.85

1.15E −7

APSO

f 1

939.20

210.12

2.36E −7

 

f 2

3172.80

446.58

1.20E −7

CAPSO

f 1

449.60

553.93

N/A

 

f 2

2004.80

46.64

N/A

  1. Hypothesis test decides significant difference of results of two methods and is shown in the p column. N/A means the data is not available