Skip to main content

Table 5 Validation of publications using different factors

From: Network slicing: a next generation 5G perspective

Author

Goal

Component units

Techniques/methods

Major features

Limitation

[18]

Analysis of RAN slicing

Spectrum planning

RAN slicing at spectrum planning level

Alternatives are presented for RAN slicing

No discussion on slicing in core network and user equipment

 

Splitting of radio resources among slices

Inter-Cell Interference coordination (ICIC)

RAN slicing at ICIC Level

  
  

Packet scheduling

RAN slicing for packet scheduling

  
  

Admission control

RAN slicing for admission control

  

[20]

Enable customisation for different users

Hypervisor

RAN slicing for C/U plane separation

Separation of control and user plane creation of network slices

Discussion missing on effects of separation of planes on slicing

  

Controller

   
  

Fronthaul

   

[28]

Customise mobile telco services

Slice plane

PERMIT framework

Achieving flexibility, efficiency, and scalability by creating on-demand VMN slices

 
  

VMN slice orchestrator

   
  

Virtual resources

   
  

Physical infrastructure

   
 

Combining SDN, NFV and cloud and edge

Users

   
  

VFN manager

   
  

NFV orchestrator

   
  

Virtualised infrastructure manager

   

[19]

Provide a logical architecture

Core cloud

Mobility management scheme

Mobility management

Latency issues in network slice management due to space limitations are not addressed

  

Edge cloud

   
  

Access unit

   
 

Managing mobility

Control unit

5G network slicing

  
  

Data unit

   
  

Application

   
  

Virtualised infrastructure management

   
  

VNF management

   
  

SDN controller

   
  

Management and orchestration

   

[21]

End-to-end network slicing

Compute nodes

Device triggered network control

Slice selection mechanism

Lack of depth in architectural features

  

SDN controller

   
  

Forwarding elements

   
  

SDN controller switch

End-to-end network slicing architecture

  
  

Physical link

   
  

5G network slices

   

[22]

Identify design challenges

User equipment

RAN slicing

Establish configuration of RAN node for RAN slicing

Involves RAN slicing only

  

RAN

   
 

Realise and customise RAN slices

Core network

   

[29]

Reducing handoff cost

RAN

RAN slicing

Machine learning with less impact on the throughput

More overhead on the user equipment

  

User equipment

   
 

Better utilisation of the throughput

Third party for encryption

   

[30]

Maximising resource utilisation

RAN

End-to-end network slicing

Machine learning with less impact on the throughput

Latency issues are not addressed

  

Core network

   

[31]

Minimise latency

RAN

RAN slicing

Low latency and packet loss with better traffic management

The system evaluated under small use case

 

Better throughput

SDN controller

   
 

Managing traffic

SDN agent

   

[32]

End-to-end network slicing testbed architecture

RAN

End-to-end network slicing

Open source

Limited parameters

  

Cloud-based SDN/NFV

 

Flexibility

Architecture is not clear