- Research Article
- Open Access
DFT-Based Channel Estimation with Symmetric Extension for OFDMA Systems
EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking volume 2009, Article number: 647130 (2008)
A novel partial frequency response channel estimator is proposed for OFDMA systems. First, the partial frequency response is obtained by least square (LS) method. The conventional discrete Fourier transform (DFT) method will eliminate the noise in time domain. However, after inverse discrete Fourier transform (IDFT) of partial frequency response, the channel impulse response will leak to all taps. As the leakage power and noise are mixed up, the conventional method will not only eliminate the noise, but also lose the useful leaked channel impulse response and result in mean square error (MSE) floor. In order to reduce MSE of the conventional DFT estimator, we have proposed the novel symmetric extension method to reduce the leakage power. The estimates of partial frequency response are extended symmetrically. After IDFT of the symmetric extended signal, the leakage power of channel impulse response is self-cancelled efficiently. Then, the noise power can be eliminated with very small leakage power loss. The computational complexity is very small, and the simulation results show that the accuracy of our estimator has increased significantly compared with the conventional DFT-based channel estimator.
The orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM) is an effective technique for combating multipath fading and for high-bit-rate transmission over mobile wireless channels. In OFDM system, the entire channel is divided into many narrow subchannels, which are transmitted in parallel, thereby increasing the symbol duration and reducing the ISI.
Channel estimation has been successfully used to improve the performance of OFDM systems. It is crucial for diversity combination, coherent detection, and space-time coding. Various OFDM channel estimation schemes have been proposed in literature. The LS or the linear minimum mean square error (LMMSE) estimation was proposed in . Reference  also proposed a low-complexity LMMSE estimation method by partitioning off channel covariance matrix into some small matrices on the basis of coherent bandwidth. However, these modified LMMSE methods still have quite high-computational complexity for practical implementation and require exact channel covariance matrices. Reference  introduced additional DFT processing to obtain the frequency response of LS-estimated channel. In contrast to the frequency-domain estimation, the transform-domain estimation method uses the time-domain properties of channels. Since a channel impulse response is not longer than the guard interval in OFDM system, the LS and the LMMSE were modified in [4, 5] by limiting the number of channel taps in time domain. References [6, 7] showed the performance of various channel estimation methods and yielded that the DFT-based estimation can achieve significant performance benefits if the maximum channel delay is known. References [8–11] improved upon this idea by considering only the most significant channel taps. Reference  further investigated how to eliminate the noise on the insignificant taps by optimal threshold.
However, in many applications such as OFDMA system, only the estimates of partial frequency response are available, and the estimate of channel impulse response in time domain cannot be obtained from the conventional DFT method. After IDFT of partial frequency response, the channel impulse response will leak to all taps in time domain. As the noise and leakage power are mixed up, the conventional DFT method will not only eliminate the noise, but also lose the useful channel leakage power and result in MSE floor. We have proposed the novel symmetric extension method to reduce the leakage power. The mathematic expression of the MSE of the conventional DFT estimator and the upper bound of the MSE of our proposed estimator are derived in this paper.
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes the system model and briefly introduces the statistics of mobile wireless channel. Section 3 proposes the novel channel-estimation approach for OFDMA systems. Section 4 presents computer simulation results to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed estimation approach. Finally, conclusion is given in Section 5.
2. System and Channel Model
Consider an OFDMA system that has subcarriers. The data stream is modulated by inverse fast Fourier transform (IFFT), and a guard interval is added for every OFDM symbol to eliminate ISI caused by multipath fading channel. At the receiver, with the th OFDM symbol, the th subcarrier of the received signal is denoted as
where are the pilot subcarriers, for simplicity, it is assumed that , represents the channel frequency response on the th subcarrier. is the AWGN with zero mean and variance of .
The complex baseband representation of the mobile wireless channel impulse response can be described by 
where is the delay of the th path, is the corresponding complex amplitude, and is the shaping pulse. For OFDM systems with proper cyclic extension and timing, it has been shown in  that the channel frequency response can be expressed as
where , and in the above expression are the block length and the symbol duration, respectively. In (3), , for , are WSS narrowband complex Gaussian processes. is the number of multipath taps. The average power of and depends on the delay profile and dispersion of the wireless channels.
3. Channel Estimation Based on Symmetric Extension
3.1. Conventional DFT Method
For simplicity, the index is omitted in the following formulation. The LS channel estimator is denoted as
After IFFT, the time-domain expression of is denoted as
where is the channel impulse response on the th path . Most mobile wireless channels are characterized by discrete multipath arrivals, that is, the magnitude of for most is zeros or very small; hence, these channel taps can be ignored. Assume denote the length of guard interval, then the maximum length of nonzero is , and for . In the conventional DFT method, in order to eliminate the noise,
The estimate of frequency response is denoted as
The basic block diagram of DFT-based estimation is shown in Figure 1.
3.2. Partial Frequency Response by Conventional DFT
In OFDMA system, as the pilot only occupies part of total subcarriers, we can only get the estimates of partial frequency response, which is denoted as
where is the length of partial frequency response. For simplicity, we consider in this paper. However, with only minor modification, the result discussed here is applicable to any . The point IFFT result of is denoted as
where , and is denoted as
where . From (10), it can be seen that the channel impulse response will leak to all taps of . The conventional DFT method is no longer applicable as will be nonzero due to the power leakage; the noise and leakage power are mixed up. The elimination of noise will also cause the loss of useful channel impulse response leakage.
It is assumed that each path is an independent zero-mean complex Gaussian random process. The leakage power-to-noise power ratio (LNR) on the th tap in the conventional DFT method can be denoted as
where is the average power of the th path. As the channel power mainly focuses on the low-frequency band, in order to eliminate the noise in high-frequency band, let denote the threshold, and the noise is eliminated by the conventional DFT method,
The corresponding estimate of partial frequency response is denoted as
The basic block diagram of partial frequency response DFT-based estimation is shown in Figure 2.
3.3. Partial Frequency Response Estimation by Symmetric Extension Method
As are the samples of the continuous and periodic channel frequency response, in time domain, the IFFT result of will only concentrate on a few taps. However, the IFFT result of the partial frequency response samples will leak to all taps. This is because are the samples of partial-frequency response, and after periodic expansion, the continuity of the signal is severely destroyed. If the leakage power is reduced significantly compared with the noise power, the noise still can be eliminated efficiently with very small loss of leakage power. Inspired by this, in order to reduce the leakage power, we have proposed the novel symmetric extension method to construct a new sequence with better continuity. is extended with symmetric signal of its own, and the symmetrically extended signal is denoted as
After point IFFT, the time-domain expression of is denoted as :
where , and is denoted as
The leakage power-to-noise power ratio (LNR) on the th tap can be denoted as
Let denote the threshold. Using the conventional DFT method, the noise and leakage power is eliminated by
After point FFT,
The corresponding estimate of partial frequency response is denoted as
The basic block diagram of our proposed symmetric extension DFT-based estimation is shown in Figure 3.
3.4. Performance Analysis
From (13), the MSE of the conventional DFT method without symmetric extension is written as
From (20), the MSE of our proposed estimator is
The estimation error of the conventional method is divided into two parts. The first part is that when , the leakage power is lost as it is forced to be zero. The second part is that when or , the error is caused by AWGN. The estimation error can be written as
Similarly, the estimation error of our proposed method is also divided into two parts. It can be written as
According to the Parseval theorem, (21) can be written as
From (24), (22) can be rewritten as
According to the Parseval theorem,
From (26), (27), the upper bound of the MSE of our proposed estimator is
3.5. Estimator Complexity
The conventional DFT-based channel estimator is very attractive for its good performance and low complexity. Its main computation complexity is point IFFT and FFT. Our proposed symmetric extension method also inherits the low complexity of the DFT estimator, and its main computation complexity is point IFFT and FFT. As the complexity of FFT and IFFT is significantly reduced nowadays, our proposed method can provide a good tradeoff between performance and complexity.
4. Performance Results
We investigate the performance of our proposed estimator through computer simulation. An OFDMA system with subcarriers is considered the guard interval . The sampling rate is 7.68 MHz, and subcarrier frequency space is 15 kHz. A six-path channel model is used. The power profile is given by dB, and the delay profile after sampling is . Each path is an independent zero-mean complex Gaussian random process.
Figures 4 and 5 show the comparison of between the conventional DFT method and our proposed method. is normalized to 1, and is set to 16 and 64. It should be noted that the FFT length of the conventional DFT method is , while the FFT length of our proposed method is due to the symmetric extension. That is why the two curves have different lengths. It is shown that is much larger than . Compared with the conventional method, the leakage power is significantly self-cancelled by symmetric extension method.
Figure 6 shows the theoretical MSE of the conventional DFT method when . The MSE is calculated under dB, 10 dB, and 20 dB, respectively. The MSE is large when is small, this is because although most noise can be eliminated, the channel power is also lost, and the MSE is mainly caused by the loss of . When is large, although the loss of is small, the noise cannot be eliminated efficiently, and the MSE is mainly caused by the noise.
Figure 7 shows the upper bound of the MSE of our proposed method. Compared with Figure 6, the upper bound of the MSE of our proposed method is smaller than the MSE of the conventional DFT method. This is because in our proposed method the channel leakage is significantly reduced, and the elimination of noise will cause less channel leakage power loss.
Figure 8 shows the MSE performance comparison of different methods. is set to 16. In the conventional DFT method, is set to 4 and 6 as the FFT length of our proposed method is doubled, and the corresponding threshold is set to 8 and 12. When SNR is low, both the conventional DFT method and our proposed method can reduce the MSE. However, when SNR is higher than 15 dB, there is an evident MSE floor larger than in the conventional DFT method. While in our proposed method, the MSE floor is eliminated efficiently. This is because when SNR is low, the MSE is mainly caused by the noise, not the loss of channel leakage power. When SNR is high, the MSE is mainly caused by the leakage power loss instead. As the leakage power is significantly reduced in our proposed symmetric extension method, even when SNR is high, the noise still can be eliminated at very small expense of channel leakage power loss. Figure 8 also shows the effect of threshold. It can be seen that when SNR is low, smaller threshold has better MSE performance than larger threshold, and when SNR is high, it has worse MSE performance. This is because with the decrease of threshold, more noise can be eliminated, but more channel leakage power will be lost, and with the increase of threshold, less channel leakage power will be lost, but less noise is eliminated.
Figure 9 shows the MSE performance when is set to 64, is set to 16 and 24, and is 32 and 48. The simulation result is similar to Figure 8. It proves that our method is effective for different values of .
Figure 10 shows the raw BER performance with different channel estimation methods. Each subcarrier is modulated by 16 QAM. is set to 16, , and . The channel is equalized by zero-forcing algorithm. It can be seen that the BER with the conventional DFT channel estimator still encounters BER floor because of the channel estimation errors. While in our proposed symmetric extension method, as the accuracy of channel estimator is significantly increased, the BER performance is also improved.
A simple DFT-based channel estimation method with symmetric extension is proposed in this paper. In order to increase the estimation accuracy, the noise is eliminated in time domain. As both the noise and the channel impulse leakage power will be eliminated, we have proposed the novel symmetric extension method to reduce the channel leakage power. The noise can be efficiently eliminated with very small loss of channel leakage power. The simulation results show that, compared with the conventional DFT method, the MSE of our proposed method is significantly reduced.
Edfors O, Sandell M, van de Beek J-J, Wilson SK, Borjesson PO: OFDM channel estimation by singular value decomposition. IEEE Transactions on Communications 1998, 46(7):931-939. 10.1109/26.701321
Noh M, Lee Y, Park H: Low complexity LMMSE channel estimation for OFDM. IEE Proceedings: Communications 2006, 153(5):645-650. 10.1049/ip-com:20050026
Zhao Y, Huang A: A novel channel estimation method for OFDM mobile communication systems based on pilot signals and transform-domain processing. Proceedings of the 47th IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference (VTC '97), May 1997, Phoenix, Ariz, USA 3: 2089-2093.
van de Beek J-J, Edfors O, Sandell M, Wilson SK, Borjesson PO: On channel estimation in OFDM systems. Proceedings of the 45th IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference (VTC '95), July 1995, Chicago, Ill, USA 2: 815-819.
Edfors O, Sandell M, van de Beek J-J, Wilson SK, Borjesson PO: Analysis of DFT-based channel estimators for OFDM. Wireless Personal Communications 2000, 12(1):55-70. 10.1023/A:1008864109605
Dowler A, Doufexi A, Nix A: Performance evaluation of channel estimation techniques for a mobile fourth generation wide area OFDM system. Proceedings of the 56th IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference (VTC '02), September 2002, Vancouver, Canada 4: 2036-2040.
Yang B, Letaief KB, Cheng RS, Cao Z: Channel estimation for OFDM transmission in multipath fading channels based on parametric channel modeling. IEEE Transactions on Communications 2001, 49(3):467-479. 10.1109/26.911454
Minn H, Bhargava VK: An investigation into time-domain approach for OFDM channel estimation. IEEE Transactions on Broadcasting 2000, 46(4):240-248. 10.1109/11.898744
Raghavendra MR, Giridhar K: Improving channel estimation in OFDM systems for sparse multipath channels. IEEE Signal Processing Letters 2005, 12(1):52-55.
Simeone O, Bar-Ness Y, Spagnolini U: Pilot-based channel estimation for OFDM systems by tracking the delay-subspace. IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications 2004, 3(1):315-325. 10.1109/TWC.2003.819022
Oliver J, Aravind R, Prabhu KMM: Sparse channel estimation in OFDM systems by threshold-based pruning. Electronics Letters 2008, 44(13):830-832. 10.1049/el:20081089
Yi W, Lihua L, Ping Z, Zemin L: Optimal threshold for channel estimation in MIMO-OFDM system. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC '08), May 2008, Beijing, China 4376-4380.
Steele R: Mobile Radio Communications. IEEE Press, New York, NY, USA; 1992.
Li Y, Cimini LJ Jr., Sollenberger NR: Robust channel estimation for OFDM systems with rapid dispersive fading channels. IEEE Transactions on Communications 1998, 46(7):902-915. 10.1109/26.701317
About this article
Cite this article
Wang, Y., Li, L., Zhang, P. et al. DFT-Based Channel Estimation with Symmetric Extension for OFDMA Systems. J Wireless Com Network 2009, 647130 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1155/2009/647130
- Mean Square Error
- Channel Estimation
- Channel Impulse Response
- OFDMA System
- Channel Estimator