Performance Analysis of Two-Hop OSTBC Transmission over Rayleigh Fading Channels
© Guangping Li et al. 2010
Received: 19 March 2010
Accepted: 26 September 2010
Published: 29 September 2010
A two-hop amplify and forward (AF) relay system is considered where source and destination are each equipped with multiple antennas while the relay has a single antenna. Orthogonal space-time block coding (OSTBC) is employed at the source. New exact expressions for outage probability in Rayleigh fading as well as symbol error rate (SER) expressions for a variety of modulation schemes are derived. The diversity order of the system is evaluated. Monte Carlo simulations demonstrate the accuracy of the analyses presented. Results that can be extended to relay systems with a direct source-destination link are also highlighted. To put the results in context, the two-hop system performance is then compared to that of a MIMO point-to-point system. Finally, the new analysis is applied to evaluate two-hop system performance as a function of relay location.
Through exploiting spatial diversity, it is well known that MIMO technology can improve the reliability of wireless communication links . Orthogonal space-time block coding (OSTBC) is a key component of MIMO systems that has attracted tremendous attention. First, OSTBC does not require complicated feedback links to provide channel state information at the transmitter (CSIT). Second, OSTBC methods enable maximum likelihood detection to be performed with low computational complexity . As a result of its practicality, OSTBC has been incorporated into emerging MIMO standards .
While MIMO systems offer significant physical layer performance enhancements, a significant problem in initial wireless network deployments is obtaining adequate coverage. The concept of relaying signals through intermediate nodes has been shown to be effective at extending the coverage of networks in a power-efficient manner. In addition, very simple relaying systems have been shown to increase diversity through node collaboration. As a result, the provision for relaying has recently been adopted into recent standards . This paper investigates the effect of simple relaying on MIMO system performance.
Previously, end-to-end performance of two-hop relay systems was studied in [5–7], including outage probability and average bit error rate (BER) in a variety of fading environments. However, in [5–7] all assume a single antenna at both source and destination. Recently, a two-hop amplify and forward (AF) relay system in which the source and destination are both equipped with multiple antennas while the relay has a single antenna appears in [8, 9]. In , an OSTBC strategy is employed at the source, and end-to-end average bit error rate (BER) was investigated. However, the method in  is only suitable for systems with the same numbers of antennas at the source and destination. Moreover, an exact expression for outage probability was not given, and the diversity order of the system was not evaluated analytically. In , system performance including outage probability and average SER is determined for the special case of multiple antennas at the source and a single antenna at the destination. Although the method used in  has been often used in the literature, it cannot be easily generalized to the case of multiple antennas at the destination.
In this paper, the same system model is assumed as in [8, 9]. First, exact expressions for system outage probability with both exact and ideal relay gain are derived for arbitrary antenna configurations at the source and destination. Exact average SER expressions for different modulation schemes are then derived by calculating the probability density function (PDF) and moment generation method (MGF). Generalizations of results to systems that include a direct link are also briefly indicated where applicable. The diversity order of the system is also evaluated. Monte Carlo simulations confirm the analytical results, compare performance between the proposed relaying system and a MIMO point-to-point system as well as evaluate the two-hop system performance as a function of relay location.
2. System Model
Using maximum likelihood (ML) detection of OSTBCs for the case of spatially colored noise given in , the received SNR is obtained as follows.
Using maximal ratio combining (MRC) at the destination, Theorem 1 can be generalized to the case of relay systems with a direct link by including a term corresponding to the SNR of the direct link that increases the SNR by , where is the Rayleigh fading complex channel gain matrix from source to destination and denotes the received noise variance during the source-to-destination time slot. It is assumed that relay-to-destination communication occurs in a separate second time slot, that is, half-duplex communication.
3. Outage Probability
In this section, analytical expressions for outage probability are derived.
4. Exact Average SER Expressions for Different Modulation Schemes
In this section, exact SER expressions for different modulation schemes are derived assuming an ideal relay gain.
(i)First, we consider modulation schemes that have conditional SER , for example, BPSK, BFSK, and MPAM.
(ii)Next, we consider the modulation schemes of MPSK and MQAM.
Proof of Lemma 5.
Proof of Theorem 4.
Finally, from Theorem 4, substituting MGF (27) for the ideal relay gain into (25) and (26), respectively, we obtain exact average SER expressions for MPSK and MQAM.
The SER expressions for MPSK and MQAM can straightforwardly be generalized to a system with a direct link. The MGF would be multiplied by the factor , where is the rate parameter of the exponentially distributed source-to-destination gain .
5. Diversity Order Analysis
6. Numerical Results and Conclusions
Figure 3 compares Monte Carlo simulations and analytical results for modulations with conditional SER including BPSK, BFSK, and 4 PAM as well as with QPSK and 16 QAM. Clearly, the simulations very closely match the analyses. Again, the ideal relay gain provides a tight lower bound on average SER even in the case of medium SNR.
Figure 4 shows average SER with BPSK modulation for different antenna configurations. Here, the diversity order can be observed as the slope of the average SER curve. In accordance with Theorem 7, it is observed that the diversity order cannot be improved through simply adding transmit or receive antennas for the case of equal numbers of source and destination antennas.
Specifically, the relay is assumed to be placed halfway between the source and destination in Figure 5. Figure 5 shows how system performance trades off between the relaying and MIMO point-to-point systems. As expected, the results clearly show that the diversity order of the MIMO point-to-point system, which is known to be , is larger than that of the relaying system for the same antenna configuration at both source and destination. In other words, as transmit SNR increases, the MIMO point-to-point system has an advantage over the relaying system. However, it can also be observed that the relaying system outperforms the MIMO point-to-point system in lower SNR regimes: for the case of , the relay system outperforms point-to-point MIMO systems at transmit SNRs below 6 dB. Adding a transmit antenna to the MIMO system lowers this threshold to -1 dB, while at the same time, the code rate for OSTBCs becomes 3/4. On the other hand, adding a receive antenna to the MIMO system lowers this threshold to -4 dB. Of course, the MIMO point-to-point system would be able to achieve similar system performance gain by adding transmit or receive antennas, but this would increase complexity.
The performance of a MIMO system using OSTBC transmission that encounters a simple relay in a two-hop AF configuration has been analyzed, including outage probability, SER and diversity order. These results extend those found in [8, 10]. Monte Carlo simulations are found to agree closely with the analyses. In fact, the numerical results indicate that tight lower bounds are obtainable using the ideal relay gain approximation, even at SNRs as low as 5–8 dB. In addition, Monte Carlo simulations also compare system performance between the proposed relaying system and a MIMO point-point system and assess performance as a function of location of the relay between the source and destination.
This paper was supported in part by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada Discovery (Grant no. 41731) and the Natural Science Foundation of Guangdong Province, China (Grant no. 10451009001004407).
- Gesbert D, Shafi M, Shiu D-S, Smith PJ, Naguib A: From theory to practice: an overview of MIMO space-time coded wireless systems. IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications 2003, 21(3):281-302. 10.1109/JSAC.2003.809458View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Tarokh V, Jafarkhani H, Calderbank AR: Space-time block codes from orthogonal designs. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 1999, 45(5):1456-1467. 10.1109/18.771146MathSciNetView ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar
- IEEE 802.16-2009 : Part 16: Air Interface for Broadband Wireless Access Systems. June 2009Google Scholar
- IEEE Unapproved Draft Std P802.11s/D3.0 : Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and PhysicalLayer (PHY) specifications Amendment 10: Mesh Networking. March 2009Google Scholar
- Hasna MO, Alouini M-S: End-to-end performance of transmission systems with relays over Rayleigh-fading channels. IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications 2003, 2(6):1126-1131. 10.1109/TWC.2003.819030View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Tsiftsis TA, Karagiannidis GK, Takis Mathiopoulos P, Kotsopoulos SA: Nonregenerative dual-hop cooperative links with selection diversity. EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking 2006, 2006:-8.Google Scholar
- Suraweera HA, Louie RHY, Li Y, Karagiannidis GK, Vucetic B: Two hop amplify-and-forward transmission in mixed Rayleigh and Rician fading channels. IEEE Communications Letters 2009, 13(4):227-229.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lee I-H, Kim D: End-to-end BER analysis for dual-hop OSTBC transmissions over Rayleigh fading channels. IEEE Transactions on Communications 2008, 56(3):347-351.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Louie RHY, Li Y, Vucetic B: Performance analysis of beamforming in two hop amplify and forward relay networks. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC '08), 2008, Beijing, China 4311-4315.Google Scholar
- Chen S, Wang W, Zhang X, Sun Z: Performance analysis of ostbc transmission in amplify-and-forward cooperative relay networks. IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology 2010, 59(1):105-113.MathSciNetView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Larsson EG, Stoica P: Space-Time Block Coding for Wireless Communications. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK; 2003.View ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar
- Li X, Luo T, Yue G, Yin C: A squaring method to simplify the decoding of orthogonal space-time block codes. IEEE Transactions on Communications 2001, 49(10):1700-1703. 10.1109/26.957388View ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar
- Golub GH, Loan CFV: Matrix Computations. JHU Press; 1996.MATHGoogle Scholar
- Proakis JG, Salehi M: Digital Communications. 5th edition. McGraw Hill Higher Education; 2008.Google Scholar
- Gradshteyn IS, Ryzhik IM, Jeffrey A: Table of Integrals, Series, and Products. 6th edition. Academic Press; 2000.MATHGoogle Scholar
- Chen Y, Tellambura C: Distribution functions of selection combiner output in equally correlated Rayleigh, Rician, and Nakagami-m fading channels. IEEE Transactions on Communications 2004, 52(11):1948-1956. 10.1109/TCOMM.2004.836596View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Simon MK, Alouini M: Digital Communication over Fading Channels. 2nd edition. Wiley-IEEE Press; 2004.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yuksel M, Erkip E: Multiple-antenna cooperative wireless systems: a diversity-multiplexing tradeoff perspective. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 2007, 53(10):3371-3393.MathSciNetView ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar
- Laneman JN, Wornell GW: Distributed space-time-coded protocols for exploiting cooperative diversity in wireless networks. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 2003, 49(10):2415-2425. 10.1109/TIT.2003.817829MathSciNetView ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.