- Research Article
- Open Access
Error Probability of DPPM UWB Systems over Nakagami Fading Channels with Receive Diversity
© Hao Zhang et al. 2011
- Received: 5 May 2010
- Accepted: 13 February 2011
- Published: 13 March 2011
We consider differential-pulse position modulation (DPPM) in an ultra wideband (UWB) communication system. A typical format for a DPPM signal in a UWB system is derived from that of a pulse position modulation (PPM) signal. The error probabilities of a UWB DPPM system with receive diversity over additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) and Nakagami fading channels are derived. Both single-user and multiuser environments are considered. Performance results are presented which show that the frame error rate (FER) with DPPM is better than that with PPM, and the FER performance can be improved significantly by receive diversity.
- Additive White Gaussian Noise
- Packet Error Rate
- Frame Error Rate
- Additive White Gaussian Noise Channel
PPM has been used extensively in optical communication systems and is the modulation employed in the IEEE 802.11 infrared physical layer standard . However, PPM adds complexity to the system since both slot and symbol synchronization are required at the receiver in order to demodulate the incoming signal . Thus DPPM has been proposed as an alternative to PPM [3, 4]. DPPM provides a higher transmission capacity by deleting redundant slots in a symbol. It does not require symbol synchronization since each symbol ends with a "1" pulse.
In recent years, DPPM has drawn wide attention as a promising modulation scheme for optical and short range radio communication. In , the code properties and spectral characteristics of a type of DPPM called digital pulse interval modulation (DPIM) were discussed. The probability of error with DPIM in optical wireless communication systems was also presented; in , the packet error rate (PER) was derived for a simple threshold detection-based receiver. It was shown that the PER of DPPM for a given average received irradiance was superior to that with on-off keying (OOK), but PPM was better than DPPM. For a given bandwidth, DPPM was shown in  to require significantly less average power than PPM. The performance of DPPM in the presence of multipath intersymbol interference (ISI) was also examined. A hybrid modulation technique called differential amplitude pulse position modulation (DAPPM) was recently proposed in . DAPPM is a combination of pulse amplitude modulation (PAM) and DPPM. The symbol structure and properties of DAPPM, for example, peak-to-average power ratio (PAPR), bandwidth requirements, and throughput, were compared with other techniques such as DPIM.
Most research on DPPM considers only optical communication systems. This paper examines DPPM for use in UWB systems. The typical format of a DPPM signal in a UWB system is derived, and the error probabilities over AWGN and Nakagami fading channels are derived. Both single-user and multiuser environments are considered. Receive diversity is employed in the UWB system to improve performance. This can be achieved using a RAKE receiver or multiple receive antennas.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, the signal construction and system model over Nakagami fading channels are introduced. Section 3 presents the error probability analysis of the DPPM UWB system over both AWGN and Nakagami fading channels in a single-user environment. The performance of the DPPM system in a multiuser environment is analyzed in Section 4. Numerical results on the system performance are given in Section 5. Finally, some conclusions are given in Section 6.
2.1. Signal Construction and System Model
where is the number of pulses that form a data symbol, is the UWB pulse of duration , and is the energy per pulse. The pulse repetition interval is . is the time-hopping code, and is the PPM time shift, where we assume , .
where and is the time slot duration.
Comparison of Symbol Mapping for 4PPM and 4DPPM.
where is AWGN with power spectral density is the propagation delay of the signal sent by the th user, is the received pulse waveform, and is the receive diversity order. Receive diversity can be achieved using a RAKE receiver or multiple receive antennas. For simplicity, we employ equal gain combining (EGC) at the receiver in the following discussion.
2.2. The Statistical Model for Nakagami Fading Channels
where denotes the Gamma function, , and with . To make the channel characteristics analyzable without affecting the generality of the channel, we further define as a random variable that takes the values +1 or −1 with equal probability.
3.1. Error Probability of -ary DPPM over AWGN Channels
where . Thus are zero-mean, mutually statistically independent Gaussian random variables with equal variance .
where is the probability of frame error, is the number of symbols in a frame, and is the probability that the th symbol is in error.
3.2. Error Probability of -ary DPPM over Nakagami Fading Channels
3.2.1. Equivalent Instantaneous SNR
where is the symbol SNR of the UWB system over an AWGN channel. The equivalent SNR is the symbol SNR modified according to the number of paths and the fading coefficients.
3.2.2. Error Probability over Nakagami Fading Channels
With a simple variable transformation, the error probability of -ary DPPM over Nakagami fading channels can be obtained by substituting for in (25). The probability of frame error can then be expressed as (19).
With more than one user active in the system, multiple access interference (MAI) is the major factor limiting performance. The net effect of the MAI produced by the undesired users at the output of the desired user's correlation receiver can be modeled as a zero-mean Gaussian random variable if the number of users is large or a repetition code is used with . Based on the multiple access error probability of -ary PPM , in this section, the multiple access error probability of DPPM system is investigated. By modifying the noise distribution, the error probability analysis given in Section 3 for a single-user can be extended to multiple access systems.
4.1. Multiple Access Error Probability over AWGN Channels
4.1.1. Multiple Access Interference Model
This agrees well with the single-user analysis.
4.1.2. Multiple Access Error Probability
4.2. Multiple Access Error Probability over Indoor Fading Channels
The instantaneous SER for a multiple access UWB system with DPPM can be obtained by substituting given by (51) in (25), and the frame error probability of a multiple access DPPM system can be obtained from (19).
In this section, some analytical and Monte Carlo simulation results are presented to illustrate and verify the error probability expressions obtained previously.
The error probability of DPPM over AWGN and Nakagami fading channels with receive diversity has been studied. Both single and multiuser cases were considered. The FER performance was first derived for AWGN channels and then extended to Nakagami fading channels by averaging the SNR over the channel random variable. Exact error probability expressions were derived, and Monte-Carlo simulation was employed for efficient evaluation. It was shown that for a UWB system, DPPM is superior to PPM in FER performance over both AWGN and Nakagami fading channels, and the FER performance can be significantly improved by employing receive diversity.
This work was supported by National 863 Hi-Tech Research and Development Program of China under Grant no. 2007AA12Z317, New Century Educational Talents Plan of Chinese Education Ministry under Grant no. NCET-08-0504, and Shandong province Nature Science Foundation under Grant no. JQ200821.
- Moreira AJC, Valadas RT, de Oliveira Duarte AM: Performance evaluation of the IEEE 802.11 infrared physical layer. Proceedings of the International Symposium on Communication Systems and Digital Signal Processing, 1998 10-15.Google Scholar
- Elmirghani JMH, Cryan RA: Analytic and numeric modelling of optical fibre PPM slot and frame spectral properties with application to timing extraction. IEE Proceedings: Communications 1994, 141(6):379-389. 10.1049/ip-com:19941536View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wilson B, Ghassemlooy ZF, Kaluarachchi ED: Digital pulse interval modulation for fiber transmission. Collision Avoidance and Automated Traffic Management Sensors, October 1995, Proceedings of SPIE 53-59.Google Scholar
- Kaluarachchi ED, Ghassemlooy Z, Wilson B: Digital pulse interval modulation for transmission over optical fibre with direct detection. All-Optical Communication Systems: Architecture, Control and Network Issues II, November 1996, Proceedings of SPIE 98-105.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kaluarachchi ED: Digital pulse interval modulation for optical communication systems, Ph.D. thesis. Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield, UK; 1997.Google Scholar
- Ghassemlooy Z, Hayes AR, Seed NL, Kaluarachchi ED: Digital pulse interval modulation for optical communications. IEEE Communications Magazine 1998, 36(12):95-99. 10.1109/35.735885View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Shiu DS, Kahn JM: Differential pulse-position modulation for power-efficient optical communication. IEEE Transactions on Communications 1999, 47(8):1201-1210. 10.1109/26.780456View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sethakaset U, Gulliver TA: Differential amplitude pulse-position modulation for indoor wireless optical communications. EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking 2005, 2005:-9.Google Scholar
- Zhao L, Haimovich AM: Capacity of M-ary PPM ultra-wideband communications over AWGN channels. Proceedings of the IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference (VTC '01), October 2001 1191-1195.Google Scholar
- Ramirez-Mireles F, Scholtz RA: Multiple-access performance limits with time hopping and pulse position modulation. Proceedings of the IEEE Military Communications Conference, October 1998 529-533.Google Scholar
- Zhang H, Udagawa T, Arita T, Nakagawa M: A statistical model for the small-scale multipath fading characteristics of ultrawide band in-door channel. Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Ultra Wideband Systems and Technologies, May 2002 81-85.Google Scholar
- Proakis JG: Digital Communications. 4th edition. McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, USA; 2001.Google Scholar
- Hayes AR, Ghassemlooy Z, Seed NL: Optical wireless communication using digital pulse interval modulation. Proceedings of the Optical Wireless Communications, November 1998, Boston, Mass, USA, Proceedings of SPIE 3532: 61-69.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Zhang H, Gulliver TA: Performance and capacity of PAM and PPM UWB time-hopping multiple access communications with receive diversity. EURASIP Journal on Applied Signal Processing 2005, 2005(3):306-315. 10.1155/ASP.2005.306View ArticleMATHGoogle Scholar
- Win MZ, Scholtz RA: Ultra-wide bandwidth time-hopping spread-spectrum impulse radio for wireless multiple-access communications. IEEE Transactions on Communications 2000, 48(4):679-691. 10.1109/26.843135View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Durisi G, Romano G: On the validity of Gaussian approximation to characterize the multiuser capacity of UWB TH PPM. Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Ultra Wideband systems and Technologies (UWBST '02), May 2002 157-161.Google Scholar
- Zhao L, Haimovich AM: The capacity of an UWB multiple-access communications system. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC '02), May 2002 1964-1968.Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.