Performance Analysis of Ad Hoc Dispersed Spectrum Cognitive Radio Networks over Fading Channels
© Khalid A. Qaraqe et al. 2011
Received: 1 September 2010
Accepted: 19 January 2011
Published: 15 February 2011
Cognitive radio systems can utilize dispersed spectrum, and thus such approach is known as dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems. In this paper, we first provide the performance analysis of such systems over fading channels. We derive the average symbol error probability of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems for two cases, where the channel for each frequency diversity band experiences independent and dependent Nakagami- fading. In addition, the derivation is extended to include the effects of modulation type and order by considering M-ary phase-shift keying ( -PSK) and M-ary quadrature amplitude modulation -QAM) schemes. We then consider the deployment of such cognitive radio systems in an ad hoc fashion. We consider an ad hoc dispersed spectrum cognitive radio network, where the nodes are assumed to be distributed in three dimension (3D). We derive the effective transport capacity considering a cubic grid distribution. Numerical results are presented to verify the theoretical analysis and show the performance of such networks.
Theoretical limits for the time delay estimation problem in dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems are investigated in . In this study, Cramer-Rao Lower Bounds (CRLBs) for known and unknown carrier frequency offset (CFO) are derived, and the effects of the number of available dispersed bands and modulation schemes on the CRLBs are investigated. In addition, the idea of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio is applied to ultra wide band (UWB) communications systems in . Moreover, the performance comparison of whole and dispersed spectrum utilization methods for cognitive radio systems is studied in the context of time delay estimation in . In [6, 7], a two-step time delay estimation method is proposed for dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems. In the first step of the proposed method, a maximum likelihood (ML) estimator is used for each band in order to estimate unknown parameters in that band. In the second step, the estimates from the first step are combined using various diversity combining techniques to obtain final time delay estimate. In these prior works, dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems are investigated for localization and positioning applications. More importantly, it is assumed that all channels in such systems are assumed to be independent from each other. In addition, single path flat fading channels are assumed in the prior works. However, in practice, the channels are not single path flat fading, and they may not be independent each other. Another practical factor that can also affect the performance of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio networks is the topology of nodes. In this context, several studies in the literature have studied the use of location information in order to enhance the performance of cognitive radio networks [8, 9]. It is concluded that use of network topology information could bring significant benefits to cognitive radios and networks to reduce the maximum transmission power and the spectral impact of the topology . In , the effect of nonuniform random node distributions on the throughput of medium access control (MAC) protocol is investigated through simulation without providing theoretical analysis. In , a 3D configuration-based method that provides smaller number of path and better energy efficiency is proposed. In , 2D and 3D structures for underwater sensor networks are proposed, where the main objective was to determine the minimum numbers of sensors and redundant sensor nodes for achieving communication coverage. In [14–16], the authors represent a new communication model, namely, the square configuration (2D), to reduce the internode interference (INI) and study the impact of different types of modulations over additive white gaussian noise (AWGN) and Rayleigh fading channels on the effective transport capacity. Moreover, it is assumed that the nodes are distributed based on square distribution (i.e., 2D). Notice that the effects of node distribution on the performance of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio networks have not been studied in the literature, which is another main focus of this paper.
In this paper, performance analysis of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems is carried out under practical considerations, which are modulation and coding, spectral resources, and node topology effects. In the first part of this paper, the performance analysis of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems is conducted in the context of communications applications, and average symbol error probability is used as the performance metric. Average symbol error probability is derived under two conditions, that is, the scenarios when each channel experiences independent and dependent Nakagami- fading. The derivation for both cases is extended to include the effects of modulation type and order, namely, M-ary phase-shift keying ( -PSK) and M-ary quadrature amplitude modulation ( -QAM). The effects of convolutional coding on the average symbol error probability is also investigated through computer simulations. In the second part of the paper, the expression for the effective transport capacity of ad hoc dispersed spectrum cognitive radio networks is derived, and the effects of 3D node distribution on the effective transport capacity of ad hoc dispersed spectrum cognitive radio networks are studied through computer simulations .
The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, the system, spectrum, and channel models are presented. The average symbol error probability is derived considering different fading conditions and modulation schemes in Section 3. In Section 4, the analysis of the effective transport capacity for the 3D node distribution is provided. In Section 5, numerical results are presented. Finally, the conclusions are drawn in Section 6.
2. System, Spectrum, and Channel Models
Since there is not any complete statistical or empirical spectrum utilization model reported in the literature, we consider the following spectrum utilization model. Theoretically, there are four random variables that can be used to model the spectrum utilization. These are the number of available band ( ), carrier frequency ( ), corresponding bandwidth ( ), and power spectral density (PSD) or transmit power ( ) . In the current study, is assumed to be deterministic. We also assume that PSD is constant and it is the same for all available bands, which results in a fixed SNR value. Additionally, since we consider baseband signal during analysis, the effect of such as path loss are not incorporated into the analysis. Ergo, the only random variable is the bandwidth of the available bands which is assumed to be uniformly distributed  with the limits of and , where and are the minimum and maximum available absolute bandwidths, respectively. In addition, we assume perfect synchronization in order to evaluate the performance of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems. The analysis of the system is given as follows.
Notice from (5) that dispersed spectrum utilization method can provide full SNR adaptation by selecting required number of bands adaptively in the dispersed spectrum. This enables cognitive radio systems to support goal driven and autonomous operations.
where and . We assumed single-cell and single user case in this study. However, the analysis can be extended to multiple cells and multiuser cases, which is considered as a future work. At this point, we have obtained the total SNR, and in order to provide the performance analysis the average symbol error probability for two different cases, independent and dependent channels, are derived in the following section.
3. Average Symbol Error Probability
In this section, we derive the average symbol error probability expressions of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems for both independent and dependent fading channel cases considering -PSK and -QAM modulation schemes. We selected these two modulation schemes arbitrarily. However, the analysis can be extended to other modulation types easily.
3.1. Independent Channels Case
3.2. Dependent Channels Case
To show the effects of dependent case in our system, we just need to use the covariance matrix that shows how the bands are dependent. To the best of our knowledge, unfortunately there is not empirical model or study on the dependency of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio or frequency diversity of channels, and determining such covariance matrix requires an extensive measurement campaign. However, there are studies on the dependency of space diversity channels [20, 21]. Therefore, we use two arbitrary correlation matrices for the sake of conducting the analysis here. These two arbitrary correlation matrices are linear and triangular, and they are referred to as Configuration A and Configuration B, respectively, in the current study.
4. Effective Transport Capacity
If a node needs to communicate with another node, a multihop route is first reserved and only then the packets can be transmitted without looking at the status of the channel which is based on a MAC protocol for INI: reserve and go (RESGO) . Packet generation, with each packet having a fixed length of bits, is given by a Poisson process with parameter (packets/second).
The INI experienced by the nodes in the network is mainly dependent on the node distribution and the MAC protocol.
4.1. Average Number of Hops
Assuming that the destination node is in the center, we try to calculate all the interference powers transmitting from all nodes by clustering the nodes into groups in order to find out the general formula for .
5. Numerical Results
It is known that the deployment of an ad hoc network is generally considered as two dimensions (2D). Nonetheless, because of reducing dimensionality, the deployment of the nodes in a 3D scenario are sparser than in a 2D scenario, which leads to decrease of the internodes interference, thus increasing the effective transport capacity of the system. This can be observed by comparing Figures 7 and 8.
In addition, the 3D topology of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio ad hoc network can be considered in some real applications such as sensor network in underwater, in which the nodes may be distributed in 3D . The 3D topology is more suitable to detect and observe the phenomena in the three dimensional space that cannot be observed with 2D topology .
In this paper, the performance analysis of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems is conducted considering the effects of fading, number of dispersed bands, modulation, and coding. Average symbol error probability is derived when each band undergoes independent and dependent Nakagami- fading channels. Furthermore, the average symbol error probability for both cases is extended to take the modulation effects into account. In addition, the effects of coding on symbol error probability performance are studied through computer simulations. We also study the effects of the 3D node distribution along with INI on the effective transport capacity of ad hoc dispersed spectrum cognitive radio networks. The effective transport capacity expressions are derived over fading channels considering -QAM modulation scheme. Numerical results are presented to study the effects of fading, number of dispersed bands, modulation, and coding on the performance of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems. The results show that the effects of fading, number of dispersed bands, modulation, and coding on the average symbol error probability of dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems is significant. According to the results, the effective transport capacity is saturated for intermediate bit rate values. Additionally, it is concluded that the correlation between fading channels highly affects the effective transport capacity. Note that this work can be extended to the case where the number of available bands change randomly at every spectrum sensing cycle, which is considered as a future work.
This paper was supported by Qatar National Research Fund (QNRF) under Grant NPRP 08-152-2-043.
- Mitola J, Maguire GQ: Cognitive radio: making software radios more personal. IEEE Personal Communications 1999, 6(4):13-18. 10.1109/98.788210View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ekin S, Yilmaz F, Celebi H, Qaraqe KA, Alouini M, Serpedin E: Capacity limits of spectrum-sharing systems over hyper-fading channels. Wireless Communications and Mobile Computing. In pressGoogle Scholar
- Gezici S, Celebi H, Poor HV, Arslan H: Fundamental limits on time delay estimation in dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems. IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications 2009, 8(1):78-83.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gezici S, Celebi H, Arslan H, Poor HV: Theoretical limits on time delay estimation for ultra-wideband cognitive radios. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Ultra-Wideband (ICUWB '08), September 2008 2: 177-180.Google Scholar
- Celebi H, Qaraqe KA, Arslan H: Performance comparison of time delay estimation for whole and dispersed spectrum utilization in cognitive radio systems. Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Cognitive Radio Oriented Wireless Networks and Communications (CROWNCOM '09), June 2009 1-6.Google Scholar
- Kocak F, Celebi H, Gezici S, Qaraqe KA, Arslan H, Poor HV: Time delay estimation in cognitive radio systems. Proceedings of the 3rd IEEE International Workshop on Computational Advances in Multi-Sensor Adaptive Processing (CAMSAP '09), 2009 400-403.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kocak F, Celebi H, Gezici S, Qaraqe KA, Arslan H, Poor HV: Time-delay estimation in dispersed spectrum cognitive radio systems. EURASIP Journal on Advances in Signal Processing 2010., 2010:Google Scholar
- Chen T, Zhang H, Maggio GM, Chlamtac I: Topology management in CogMesh: a cluster-based cognitive radio mesh network. In Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC '07), 2007. Citeseer; 6516-6521.Google Scholar
- Mähönen P, Petrova M, Riihijärvi J: Applications of topology information for cognitive radios and networks. Proceedings of the 2nd IEEE International Symposium on New Frontiers in Dynamic Spectrum Access Networks (DySPAN '07), April 2007 103-114.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chiganmi A, Sarac K, Prakash R: Variable power broadcasting in ad hoc networks. In Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC '06), 2006, Istanbul, Turkey. Citeseer;Google Scholar
- Hoydis J, Petrova M, Mähönen P: Effects of topology on local throughput-capacity of ad hoc networks. Proceedings of the 19th IEEE International Symposium on Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications (PIMRC '08), September 2008 1-5.Google Scholar
- Thomas RW, Komali RS, MacKenzie AB, DaSilva LA: Joint power and channel minimization in topology control: a cognitive network approach. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC '07), June 2007 6538-6544.Google Scholar
- Pompili D, Melodia T, Akyildiz IF: Three-dimensional and two-dimensional deployment analysis for underwater acoustic sensor networks. Ad Hoc Networks 2009, 7(4):778-790. 10.1016/j.adhoc.2008.07.010View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ferrari G, Baruffini B, Tonguz O: Spectral efficiency-connectivity tradeoff in ad hoc wireless network. Proceedings of the International Symposium on Information Theory and Its Applications (ISITA '04), October 2004, Parma, ItalyGoogle Scholar
- Ferrari G, Tonguz OK: MAC protocols and transport capacity in ad hoc wireless networks: Aloha versus PR-CSMA. Proceedings of the IEEE Military Communications Conference (MILCOM '03), October 2003, Boston, Mass, USA 1311-1318.Google Scholar
- Tonguz O, Ferrari G: Ad Hoc Wireless Networks: A Communication Theoretic Perspective. John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, USA; 2006.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Qaraqe KA, Mohammad M, Celebi H, El-Saigh A: The impacts of node distribution on the effective transport capacity of ad hoc dispersed spectrum cognitive radio networks. Proceedings of the 17th International Conference on Telecommunications (ICT '10), October 2010, Doha, Qatar 122-127.Google Scholar
- Celebi H, Qaraqe KA, Arslan H: Performance analysis of TOA range accuracy adaptation for cognitive radio systems. Proceedings of the 70th IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference Fall (VTC '09), September 2009, Anchorage, Alaska, USAGoogle Scholar
- Goldsmith A: Wireless Communciations. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK; 2005.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lee WCY: Mobile Communications Design Fundamentals. John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, USA; 1993.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Zhang QT: Exact analysis of postdetection combining for DPSK and NFSK systems over arbitrarily correlated nakagami channels. IEEE Transactions on Communications 1998, 46(11):1459-1467. 10.1109/26.729390View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nakagami M: The m distribution—a general formula for intensity distribution of rapid fading. In Statistical Methods in Radio Wave Propagation. Edited by: Hoffman WG. Pergamon, New York, NY, USA; 1960:3-66.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ghareeb I: Noncoherent MT-MFSK signals with diversity reception in arbitrarily correlated and unbalanced Nakagami- m fading channels. IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications 2005, 23(9):1839-1850.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lin S, Castello D: Error Control Coding. 2nd edition. Pearson, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA; 1963.Google Scholar
- Tiwari R, Dinh T, Thai M: On Approximation Algorithms for Interference-Aware Broadcast Scheduling in 2D and 3D Wireless Sensor Networks, Springer Wireless Algorithms, Systems, and Applications. Springer, New York, NY, USA; 2009.Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.